Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Lancaster, NY & compare the best quotes from them.
| Home Insurance Company | A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating | Homeowners Insurance Market share |
|---|---|---|
| GEICO | A++ | 16% |
| Erie | A+ | 11% |
| Nationwide | A+ | 9% |
| Liberty Mutual | A | 8.17% |
| American Family Insurance | A+ | 3.01% |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sean Duffy | 36 Buffalo Street 14075 |
||
| Scott Mitchell | 117 S Union Street 14559 |
||
| Kevin M Thomas Lutcf | 2860 SHERIDAN DR 14150 |
716-837-1300 | |
| Sean Goggins | 424 Main Street Suite 1901 14202 |
||
| Melba B Jones Lutcf | 2755 Buffalo Rd 14624-1337 |
(585) 429-2082 | |
| Schawn Middleton | 31 Knox Road 14052 |
||
| Marcelle J Bauch | 955 Maryvale Dr 14225 |
(716) 634-7524 | |
| Kelly Carpenter | 484 MAIN ST 14052 |
716-652-2240 | |
| Matthew Nash | 303 East Main Street 14414-1455 |
(585) 226-8604 | |
| Zachary Newman | 441 Main St. 14103 |
(585)902-4375 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Triumph Insurance Agency Llc | 316 Pine St 316 Pine St South\u00a0Dayton 14138 |
||
| Tamika M Raymond | 191 S Union St 14559 |
||
| Alan G. Shuford | 3221 Chili Ave 14624-5411 |
585-889-3210 | |
| Joseph A Amato | 8575 NIAGARA FALLS BLVD 14304 |
716-298-7540 | |
| Columbia Insurance Group Llc | 6427 Transit Rd 14051-1427 |
716-689-6653 | |
| Andy W. Bleggi | 2201 Pine Ave 14301-2300 |
716-282-5253 | |
| Thomas L. Wood | 1578 Broadway St Ste 1 14212 |
||
| Leblanc Ins Agency Inc | 7 MAIN ST 14546 |
585-889-2927 | |
| Marcelo M Campon Agency Llc | 2568 Elmwood Ave 14217-1938 |
(716) 877-8855 | |
| The Warrick Group Ltd Dba Dee Darden Warrick Agenc | 354 Cayuga Rd Ste 1 14225 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hills Insurance Agency Inc. | 602 GROVER CLEVELAND HIGHWAY SUITE A www.hillsinsagency.com 14226 |
716-836-2222 | |
| Halter Insurance Group Ltd. | 110 W Main St 14482 |
(585) 502-1040 | |
| Hershberger Insurance Agency Llc | 8810 MAIN STREET 14221 |
716-675-6666 | |
| Foradora Insurance | 31 Mechanic St www.foradorainsurance.com 14470 |
(585) 638-6313 | |
| Hershberger Insurance Agency Llc | 8810 MAIN STREET 14221 |
716-675-6666 | |
| Lowder Insurance Agency | 50 MAIN ST 14020 |
585-343-2282 | |
| Carl G Urian Insurance Inc. | 615 Elmwood Ave 14222-1811 |
716-783-9460 | |
| Southern Hills Insurance Agency Inc. | 653 Main St 14052 |
||
| Les Gerber Insurance Agency Inc. | 3229 CHILI AVENUE 14624 |
585-889-4650 | |
| Hillcrest Insurance Group Llc | 5707 MAIN ST 14221 |
716-633-1313 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jim Migas | 374 Delaware Ave Ste 308 14202 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dean Collotta | 590 E Main St 14020 |
(585) 344-1400 Email:dcollotta@geico.com |
|
| Jeff Evenson | 7336 BOSTON STATE RD 14110 |
716-649-4100 Email:jevenson@geico.com |
|
| Jay Body | 4360 PEET ST 14105 |
716-735-9401 Email:jbody@geico.com |
| American Family Insurance | GEICO | Nationwide | |
| Median Home Value ($) | 178,670 | 178,670 | 168,670 |
| Construction year | 1962 | 2013 | 2013 |
| Home Coverage ($) | $500000-$600000 | $300000-$350000 | $400000-$500000 |
| Total Premium ($) | $4573 | $2502 | $2715 |
| Home Insurance Company | Multi Policy Discount (%) |
|---|---|
| Liberty Mutual | upto 19% |
| Nationwide | upto 10% |
| Erie | upto 16% |
| American Family Insurance | upto 19% |
| GEICO | upto 14% |