Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Ontario County, NY & compare the best quotes from them.
| Home Insurance Company | A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating | Homeowners Insurance Market share |
|---|---|---|
| GEICO | A++ | 16% |
| Allstate | A+ | 14.09% |
| Erie | A+ | 11% |
| Travelers | A++ | 8.35% |
| Liberty Mutual | A | 8.17% |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lori Myers | 919 CULVER RD 14609 |
585-482-9980 Email:lmyers@geico.com |
|
| Dean Collotta | 590 E Main St 14020 |
(585) 344-1400 Email:dcollotta@geico.com |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Lyden Group Llc | 3205 Mount Read Blvd. 14616 |
(585)861-6221 | |
| Summit Insurance Group Inc | 115 E 4Th St 14891 |
||
| Halter Insurance Group Ltd. | 110 W Main St 14482 |
(585) 502-1040 | |
| Matt Roberts Agency Inc. | 745 Pre Emption Rd 14456-1335 |
(315) 789-3753 | |
| D L Townsend Insurance Agency Llc | 7257 Owasco Road 13021-5132 |
315-253-4103 | |
| Joel T Cheatham Inc. | 8468 STATE RTE 54 www.ncagent.com 14840 |
607-569-2363 | |
| Lebherz Insurance Agency Inc | 17 N MAIN ST www.lebherzinsurance.com 14472 |
585-582-6440 Email:frank@lebherzinsurance.com |
|
| Tate & Associates | 39 W Main St 13165 |
||
| J B True Company Inc. | 2509 BROWNCROFT BLVD www.trueinsurance.com 14625 |
585-381-2605 | |
| Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency | 436 E Main 14869 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kenneth Bowley | 354 GRANT AVE 13021 |
315-253-9900 | |
| Michael Steiger | 1140 Crosspointe Lane Ste 8 14580 |
1-585-787-0850 | |
| First Insurance Agency | 1880 E Ridge Rd Suite 5 Lower Level 14622 |
(585) 544-2280 | |
| Virginia Conn | 16 Virginia Street 13165 |
||
| Brian Caston | 59 Main St 14420-1903 |
585-637-5358 | |
| Scott Moore | 1577 Ridge Road W Suite 216 14615 |
||
| Dianne Peters | 272 S Main St 14424 |
(585) 396-1111 | |
| Van Dyke Rankin & Co Inc | 2652 Chili Ave vandykerankin.com 14624 |
Email:jarvis@vandykerankin.com |
|
| Angelo Torres | 2018 Latta Rd 14612-3726 |
585-697-5679 | |
| Gary P. Fryer | 136 Main Street 14527 |
(315) 536-2363 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Matthew Nash | 303 East Main Street 14414-1455 |
(585) 226-8604 | |
| Dominique Kehayias | 225 S Fulton St 14850 |
(607) 257-0606 | |
| Mary Beth Cafferty | 2359 N Triphammer Rd 14850-1059 |
(607) 257-2306 | |
| Sandy Hopkins | 115 E 4th Street 14891 |
||
| Bryan Cohen | 3030 Monroe Ave Ste 210 14618-4604 |
585-442-8771 | |
| Michael Stauss Lutcf Clu | 7387 State Route 96 14564 |
1-585-869-2962 | |
| Michelle Frey | 360 Grant Avenue Rd 13021 |
(315) 253-9900 | |
| Matt R. Smith | 1130 Crosspointe Trail Ste 9B 14580-2986 |
(585) 663-1810 | |
| Scott Mitchell | 117 S Union Street 14559 |
||
| Les Leber | 2005 LYELL AVE 14606 |
607-754-3500 |
| Homeowners Insurance Agents | Agent Address | Contact Details | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moody Davirro & Associates Inc | 95 ALLENS CREEK RD STE 2 14618 |
(585) 697-0880 | |
| Eia - David Li Insurance | 129 S Union St Ofc 120 14559 |
(585) 203-9360 | |
| Insurance Agency Services Llc | 349 W COMMERCIAL ST STE 1100 14445 |
585-264-1234 | |
| Great Fl Ins Of Largo | 680 Ridge Rd Ste 1 14580 |
(585) 787-1160 | |
| G Lewis Insurance Llc | 252 S Main St www.glewisinsurance.com 14569 |
(585) 786-3550 Email:greg@glewisinsurance.com |
|
| Insurance Agency Services Llc | 349 W COMERCIAL ST STE 1100 14445 |
716-223-9110 | |
| Johnson & Hoge Insurance Group Inc | 6336 LAKE AVE www.johnsonandhogeinsurance.com 14589 |
315-589-4751 | |
| Leblanc Insurance Brokers | 230 GEORGE ST 14511 |
585-538-6440 | |
| Family Insurance Services | 65 E Main St 14414 |
(585) 346-7444 | |
| Johnson & Wood Insurance Services Inc | 421 PENBROOKE DR STE 8 www.johnsonwood.com 14526 |
585-271-3294 Email:jwi@johnsonwood.com |
| Allstate | Erie | Travelers | |
| Median Home Value ($) | 160,850 | 160,850 | 140,850 |
| Construction year | 2010 | 1943 | 1990 |
| Home Coverage ($) | $200000-$250000 | $250000-$300000 | $300000-$350000 |
| Total Premium ($) | $1912 | $2388 | $2811 |
| Home Insurance Company | Multi Policy Discount (%) |
|---|---|
| GEICO | upto 22% |
| Erie | upto 19% |
| Allstate | upto 16% |
| Liberty Mutual | upto 16% |
| Travelers | upto 8% |