Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Otsego County, NY & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Otsego County, NY

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
GEICO A++ 16%
Allstate A+ 14.09%
State Farm A 13.09%
Erie A+ 11%
Travelers A++ 8.35%

Top Erie Home Insurance Agents in Otsego County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Lake Shore Ins Agcy Inc 7324 ROUTE 20
lakeshoreinsurance.com 13402
315-893-7790
Hall Insurance Agency Llc 5871 Rome Taberg Rd
www.hallinsurancellc.com 13440
(315) 281-2200
Lake Shore Insurance Agency Inc. 133 ALBANY ST
13035
315-655-4393
Freeman-Gingrich Insurance Agency 85 Alden P.O. Box 512
13320
(607) 264-3755
Mavrich & Mavrich Insurance 9556 Rt 7 Suite 2
www.mavrichinsurance.com 12197-2200
(607) 397-1999
The Resource Insurance Group 1070 Upper Lenox Ave Oneida
13421
Cascade Insurance Group Llc 4794 Commercial Dr Ste 2
13413-6241
315-736-6400
Joyner Insurance Agency 22-26 WATKINS AVE
13820
607-432-2022
Lake Shore Insurance Agency Inc. 29 WEST PARK ROW
13323
315-853-5052
Shumway Insurance Agency Inc. 5737 St Rte 23A
12485

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in Otsego County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Navo Financial Inc Ins & Financial Solutions 5473 FLANAGAN RD
13403
(315) 732-7027
Sutton & Tarantino Insurance Agency Inc 105 Front St
13754

Email:rods@suttoninsuranceagency.com
The Madison Group 9 Albany St
13035
Peck-Glasgow Agency Inc 2769 State Route 51
13357
(315) 895-4609
Gaudreau-Fountain Ins Agency Inc 4 S Washington Ave Ste 1
13830
(607) 843-8860
Mcconnell Agency Inc 136 East State Street
12078
(518) 725-3734
Email:mcconnins@aol.com
Flury-Hinderks Ins Agency Inc 50 N Broad St
www.fhins.com 13815
(607) 336-1444
Legacy Ins Group Inc 9220 STATE RTE 49
13403
315-736-1411
C.I.G. Insurance Agency 15 Genesee St # B
13778-1246
607-656-8111
Insurance For Life Of South Florida Inc 297 MAIN STREET
12157
518-827-5888

Top GEICO Home Insurance Agents in Otsego County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Dempsey Ballard 21 Herkimer Rd
13502
(315) 793-3322
Email:dballard@geico.com

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Otsego County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Brandon Warner 299 N Comrie Ave Ste B
www.bkwsf.com 12095-1501
518-762-1912
Fred Crump 209 Main St
www.fredcrumpins.com 13326
(607) 547-2951
Navin Jiwnani 587 MAIN ST
www.navinjiwnani.com 13417
(315) 768-3808
Jack Traffanstedt 5327 State Route 23
12496
Jeff Herr 209 Erie Blvd
13317
Jp Noak 569 MAIN ST STE 1
12043
518-234-3536
Ann Smith 430 Trenton Ave
13502-1614
315-797-7763
Pat Casey 104 Campion Commons
13413
(315)207-3051
Dru Short Casl, Clu 7 W Whitesboro St
13495
(315) 736-2300
Mary Ann Bate 64 Genesee Street
13778-1227
(607) 656-4567

Top Allstate Home Insurance Agents in Otsego County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
James Mccall 761 Main Street
12455
Scott Kendall 143 W Dominick Street
13440
Joyia Lytle AT NBT BANK 2 COMMONS DR
13326
607-547-2575
Frank Kimmel 3 Canal St
13339
(518) 993-2387
Joseph Dunn 23 N ANN STREET
13365
315-823-0400
Keith Robert Dorband 2330 STATE HIGHWAY 30A
12095
518-762-2133
Joseph Finelli CAMPION COMMONS NEW HARTFORD SHOPPING CENTER
13413
315-792-0000
Kevin W Mcdonald 55 STEWART AVE
12776
607-498-4301
Stephanie Sales 55 E Main St Norwich
13815
Wayne Copper 5375 State Highway 7 Ste 2
13838

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Otsego County, NY

TravelersErieGEICO
Median Home Value ($) 127,710137,710127,710
Construction year 200320011998
Home Coverage ($) $125000-$150000$125000-$150000$150000-$175000
Total Premium ($) $829$988$1301

Otsego County, NY Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Erie upto 16%
Travelers upto 5%
GEICO upto 23%
Allstate upto 19%