Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Tioga County, NY & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Tioga County, NY

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
State Farm A 13.09%
Erie A+ 11%
Nationwide A+ 9%
Travelers A++ 8.35%
Liberty Mutual A 8.17%

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in Tioga County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Sandy Hopkins 115 E 4th Street
14891
Markus Warwick Lutcf 382 Reuters Blvd
18848-8225
(570) 265-6911
Joel Peterson 358 S WALNUT ST
14902
607-734-3381
Ashley Stewart 3215 E Main St Ste 3
13760-5905
607-484-8400
Mary Beth Cafferty 2359 N Triphammer Rd
14850-1059
(607) 257-2306
Jody Vosburg 22 N MAIN ST
14883
607-589-4456
Christopher J. Mccauley 6129 State Highway 12
13815-2503
607-334-4222
Dominique Kehayias 225 S Fulton St
14850
(607) 257-0606
Nicole Granados 2333 N TRIPHAMMER RD
14850
(607) 266-3303
Nicole Gallardo 78 NORTH ST
13053
(607) 844-8555

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in Tioga County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Marla J Evans 372 Broad St.
14892
(607) 565-2366
Mellissa Cruz Agency Llc 103A State St
18853
(570) 746-1771
Joel R Rice 309 E WATER ST
14901
607-734-6283
Donald M Newton 82 North Ave
13827
(607) 687-6848
Jo Ann Prescott Agency 55 E MAIN ST
13815
607-334-3204
Craig J Meier 222 Elmira Road, Suite 2
14850
607-256-2886
Dietz & Associates Inc 3502 Country Club Rd
13760
(607) 748-3000
Frohnapfel Insurance Agency Inc. 28 Main St PO Box 327
18848
(570) 265-3197
O L Meek Insurance Agency Inc 825 VESTAL PKWY W
13850
(607) 754-1411
Thomas A Obrien At Nbt Bank At Nbt Bank
13778

Top Erie Home Insurance Agents in Tioga County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Sabourin Insurance Services Inc. 426 S Keystone Avenue
18840
Gary C Grant Insurance Agency Inc. 23 Main St
14837
(607) 243-7200
Miller Phillips Insurance Inc 8468 ROUTE 54
www.millerphillips.com 14840
(607) 569-2363
Email:matt@millerphillips.com
Lawing - Elvington Insurance Agency Inc. WESTSIDE PLAZA 219 MAIN ST
13905
607-729-0808
Gerelli Insurance Agency Inc. 1550 S Main St Ste 3
16933
(570) 662-7425
Joel T Cheatham Inc. 8468 STATE RTE 54
www.ncagent.com 14840
607-569-2363
Shelby Mutual Insurance Agency 436 E Main
14869
Summit Insurance Group Inc 115 E 4Th St
14891
O H Walker Insurance Agcy Inc 36 WASHINGTON AVE STE 1
www.ohwalkerins.com 13760
(607) 754-0424
Alliance Insurance Agency 1111 Triphammer Rd
14850-2512
607-257-8900

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in Tioga County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Atl Insurance Llc 672 Main St
www.myatlagency.com 13790-1845
607-798-7191
Wright-Sprayberry Ins Llc 722 S. Meadow Stree 722 S. Meadow Stree
www.wrightsprayberry.com 14850
E T Clauss & Company Inc 2010 E Main St
www.claussinsurance.com 13760
(607) 748-1100
C.I.G. Insurance Agency 15 Genesee St # B
13778-1246
607-656-8111
Aai-Mark Rendon 376 S Main St
14904-1343
607-734-0531
Law Insurance Agency Inc 263 MAIN ST
13905
607-766-2886
Gaudreau-Fountain Ins Agency Inc 4 S Washington Ave Ste 1
13830
(607) 843-8860
Fulton Agency Inc 115 E. 4th Street
14891
(607) 535-2731
Email:marie@fultonagency.com
Southeastern Agency Group 585 Main St Ste 1
www.sagnc.com 13790

Email:joshort@sagnc.com
Heberling Agcy Inc PO Box 338
18853
(570) 746-3434

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Tioga County, NY

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Nicole Simon 34 W MARKET ST
www.nicolesimon.biz 14830
(607) 937-8371
Garrett Good Rts. 7&8 Box 279
www.ggoodsf.com 13838
(607) 563-2171
Anita M Merrihew 12 Washington Ave
13760-5305
607-754-1700
Melissa Mcdonald 145 Riverside Drive
www.melissajmcdonald.com 13905
(607) 722-6479
Joel Sellers 328 BROAD ST
www.joelsellers.com 14892
607-565-8121
Jody Mcdaniel 300 N TIOGA ST
14850
607-273-4184
Nicole Grove 300 N TIOGA ST
www.nicolegrove.com 14850
607-273-4184
Jeff Shamp Rr 1 Box 63B
18848
Dave Carver 1332 Upper Front Street Suite 4
www.agentdavecarver.com 13901-1142
607-238-1355
Shawn Leh 3121
www.shawnleh.com 13850

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Tioga County, NY

Liberty MutualState FarmNationwide
Median Home Value ($) 111,700111,700101,700
Construction year 199819921963
Home Coverage ($) $150000-$175000$150000-$175000$125000-$150000
Total Premium ($) $866$1092$784

Tioga County, NY Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Liberty Mutual upto 19%
Nationwide upto 7%
Erie upto 18%
Travelers upto 8%